If Christian Science is untrue, as its opponents aver, in favor of what faith or doctrine would they have its followers abandon it? If Christian Scientists are to be allowed any Christian teaching whatsoever, what shall it be, should they renounce Christian Science? Something must take its place, and what? Will the opponents of Christian Science champion pure materialism and offer it in exchange for the pure idealism of Christian Science? That would imply the acceptance of the proposition that the Supreme Cause, the creator of the universe, is an unconscious, self-created, non-intelligent, mechanical energy or force; a self-sustained mechanism, wholly devoid of the power to reflect or know.

Do not those who would offer this proposition in exchange for the teaching of Christian Science that the great First Cause is Mind, Spirit, know that no spirituality or religion of any kind is deducible from that basis? If the dynamic agent of creation is an unconsciously working material energy, a mere self-impelled stream of physical force with no self-knowledge or conscious purpose from start to finish, then man is wholly material, and with all else, death is the fate that ends all. Given this proposition, atheism—the denial of the existence of one infinitely intelligent God or Mind as the creator of the universe, and man's ability to prove his unity or spiritual kinship with this divine power—is an inescapable conclusion. Man cannot intelligently communicate with what is not conscious and intelligent, nor can the so-called laws of matter inspire loving confidence and the desire to lead a pure and upright life.

August 10, 1907

We'd love to hear from you!

Easily submit your testimonies, articles, and poems online.