The ordinary argument against Christian Science is that...

Brixton Free Press

The ordinary argument against Christian Science is that it is contrary to the evidence of the senses, opposed to common sense, or, as it was put the other day, "a denial of facts which common sense is accustomed to regard as obviously real and self-existent." May I be permitted to say that common sense is not infrequently a polite way of saying uncommon ignorance. And if some of the people who talk so readily of common sense would read certain remarks by Huxley on the subject it would add considerably to their fund of information. "The fish of immortal memory," Huxley wrote, "who threw himself out of the frying-pan into the fire, was not more ill-advised than the man who seeks sanctuary from philosophical persecution within the walls of the observatory or the laboratory." This sanctuary seeker, according to Huxley's description, is the individual steeped in common sense.

How right Huxley was is sufficiently obvious. Common sense declares that the sun rises and sets. It declared for centuries that you could see it for yourself, and for centuries it burned men and women for denying the evidence of their God-given senses. When the metaphysical philosopher came by with his upsetting speculations, common sense shouted its version of "Great is Diana of the Ephesians." It ran to the observatory. And to its consternation the observatory answered, "The sun is stationary." Common sense again declares pain to be in the wound. Its says it knows it is there because it can feel it there, and a certain common sense philosopher prescribes a furious hating attack on people who, like Christian Scientists, deny the evidence of their God-given materiality. When the metaphysical practitioner comes upon the scene, it gathers its microbes round its skirts and vigorously declares it version of Tertullus' declaration, "We have found this man a pestilent fellow and a mover of sedition among all the Jews throughout the world; and a ringleader of the sect of the Nazarenes." In support it turns to the Felix of the laboratory; and from the mouth of one of the greatest natural scientists who ever stepped inside a laboratory it is informed, "It is utterly impossible to conceive of pain except as a state of consciousness."

March 23, 1912

We'd love to hear from you!

Easily submit your testimonies, articles, and poems online.