Article September 3, 1904 Issue

Are we Inconsistent?

WILLARD S. MATTOX.

Among the many indictments named against Christian Science by its critics, one that we most frequently come upon is that of inconsistency in the practical application of its faith. The iconoclast, who has set for himself the task of breaking down the structure of Christian Science, seems to take especial delight in finding fault with its representatives because they eat, clothe themselves, build material edifices, and enjoy the beauties of art, music, and the best in literature. We are told that such practice is not what is to be expected, logically, from those who deny the very existence of matter and assert that Spirit is the only substance.

The casual observer of this religious movement may think that in the disparity between the statements of the Christian Science text-book, and the present experience of those who are its students, he has discovered grave inconsistencies. What he has really observed is the difference between the thing itself, and the individual apprehension of that thing; the difference between the whole and a part. It is the difference we find between mathematics, and the individual demonstration of mathematics. It is the same difference observable between philosophy in the abstract, and in practice. We find, too, the same difference between any theology and the disciple's effort to live that theology in his daily life. There is, in fact, no inconsistency. If the Christian, of whatever creed, were to be judged by the same unreasonable standard, he would be obliged to plead guilty to the charge. The Christian Scientist does not pretend to be able to prove now, in his experiences, the ultimate of Christian Science, because he is only a student and not a master, and he should not be judged as though he did make such a claim.

In this connection, we may mark well what our Leader says, in "Unity of Good." After referring to the demonstration over death, she says, page 55. "The achievement of this ultimatum of Science, complete triumph over death, requires time and immense spiritual growth.

Send a comment to the editors

NEXT IN THIS ISSUE

Article

All Disease Unreal