Christian Science at an Episcopal Congress

The twentieth meeting of the Church Congress of the Episcopal Church of the United States occurred at Providence, R. I., last week, commencing at eight o'clock on Tuesday evening, November 13, 1900, at the Mathewson Street Methodist Episcopal Church.

The sessions of this Congress were for the purpose of discussing important subjects by the leaders of thought in the Episcopal Church and in some cases by distinguished laymen. A number of specially prepared papers on various topics were read. Among the important events of the occasion was an able and interesting sermon by Bishop Potter of New York.

Students: Get
JSH-Online for
$5/mo
  • Every recent & archive issue

  • Podcasts & article audio

  • Mary Baker Eddy bios & audio

Subscribe

Of the distinguished persons present and participating, we note the Rev. Henry Codman Potter, D.D., Bishop of New York; the Rev. William Lawrence, D.D., Bishop of Massachusetts, and successor of Dr. Phillips Brooks; Rt. Rev. Dr. Sidney Partridge, Bishop of Kyoto, Japan; Captain A. T. Mahan, U. S. N.; Mr. Hamilton Mabie of New York; Rev. Charles C. Tiffany, Archdeacon of New York; Rt. Rev. Dr. W. C. Doane, Bishop of Albany; Bishop Randolph of Southern Virginia; Bishop Hall of Vermont; Rt. Rev. William N. McVickar, Bishop of Rhode Island; Rev. E. S. Rousmaniere, Rector of Grace Church Parish; Rev. Frederick J. Bassett, Rector of the Church of the Redeemer; Rev. Arthur M. Aucock, of All Saints Memorial Church; Rev. E. Winchester Donald, D.D., Rector of Trinity Church, Boston, and successor to Dr. Brooks; Rev. Dr. William R. Huntington of New York; Rev. Dr. Thomas R. Harris, Scarborough, New York; Rev. Dr. Henry S. Nash, of Cambridge, Massachusetts; Rev. Dr. C. W. E. Body of New York; Rev. Dr. Charles H. Babcock, Providence; Rev. Dr. William Prall of New York; Rev. Dr. J. Lewis Parks of New York; Rev. Edgar G. Murphy of Alabama, and many others.

Among the non-ecclesiastics present we note also the names of William N. Polk, M. D., Dean of Cornell University; Prof. Theodore F. Seward of New York, who read a paper on Christian Science; W. A. Purrington, Esq., of the New York Bar, lecturer on the relation of law to medical practice in the University and Bellevue Medical College Hospital and in the New York College of Dentistry, and counsel for the New York State Medical Association; John Parks Leavitt, also a member of the New York Bar, and James H. Canfield, LL.D., of New York.

From the Providence (R. I.) Journal of Wednesday, Nov. 14, 1900, we extract the following mention of the session of the Congress which discussed the subject of Christian Science:—

"Christian Science was attacked and defended in a masterly manner at Mathewson Street Methodist Church last evening in the presence of an audience which numbered between fourteen and fifteen hundred people, which filled the auditorium to its utmost seating and standing capacity, and was pressed out into the halls by the mass of people within. The occasion was the first discussion of the twentieth annual Church Congress of the Episcopal Church of America, and the interest in the topic and the renown of the men who were to argue the matter were the loadstones for the immense gathering. The largest hall in the city would not have been too capacious for those who wished to be present at this opening discussion.

"The subject was handled without gloves by every speaker and writer on the programme. It was called all sorts of names from a religion to a cult, and one speaker persistently referred to it as Eddyism. Yet the debate was good-natured throughout, and the debaters touched the subject as wittily and brilliantly as they did logically. The half-dozen speakers and writers had each a different point of view, according to their professions of philosophical beliefs. It seemed a bit unfair that only one of the half dozen should be an avowed Christian Scientist, as well as the first on the programme, a position in which he was forced to outline the tenets of Christian Science and hold it up as a target for the flings of the others, yet this single speaker, Theodore F. Seward of New York, won his audience at the outset and proved quite equal to the burden laid on him.

"Rev. Dr. William R. Huntington of New York touched Christian Science from the standpoint of the orthodox churchman; William M. Polk, M.D., a brilliant medical man, from that of the physician, dwelling mainly on the claims of the Christian Scientists as healers; W. A. Purrington of New York, a well-known lawyer, from the point of view of medical jurisprudence; Rev. Dr. E. W. Donald of Boston, surprised his hearers by conceding rather more to the Christian Scientists than the others were willing to allow them. Altogether, the discussion was an intellectual treat of a kind Providence has not often the privilege of enjoying."

Rt. Rev. W. N. McVickar presided at the session in the absence of Bishop Clark.

As above stated, Prof. Theodore F. Seward of New York, who is a member of the Episcopal Church, was the first speaker. His presentation of the subject was concise, logical, and able. Through Mr. Seward's courtesy we are permitted to publish his address in full. It follows this account.

Mr. Seward was followed by Rev. William R. Huntington, D.D., of New York, from whose able paper we make brief excerpts:—

"There is said to be somewhere in existence in one of the examinations for church service, a question and answer which reads as follows: 'Question.—How should we treat Presbyterians? Answer.—We should treat them kindly, but not listen to their foolish talk.' In discussing Christian Science I think something of the same sort might apply.

"As we have already been assured, the distinguishing feature of Christian Science is idealism. It teaches the divine oneness of the divine, and the absolute nothingness of all else. I confess that if I had to choose this doctrine and the offerings of the materialists in the last forty years, I would choose Christian Science. In consideration of the cruel manner in which the materialists have assailed the church, it is not strange that there should have sprung up this quaint protest....

"I would urge my fellow-ministers to take pains to recognize the modicum of truth there is in Christian Science. Guard those you teach from taking the mere immaterial for the ideal. If anything is certain this is certain: That if the Church of Christ, Catholic, had done its duty, the Church of Christ, Scientist, had not been."

Dr. Huntington was followed by William N. Polk, M.D. Dr. Polk, in the course of his remarks, said:—

"The history of medicine shows that man's conceptions of the limits between the material and spiritual have shifted. The material has made serious inroads on the territory formerly held by the spiritual. Medicine, like all material agents, has its agents, and we, therefore, ask whether Christian Science occupies any field not already covered by us. Medicine has tested Christian Science. The first step was to place it. We found it to be nothing new, but a variety of that form of spiritism known by us as psychic therapeutics. The work done throughout the world by hypnotism or suggestion is the same done by Christian Science."

(The claim here made by Dr. Polk is being so generally made by the medical profession as well as some theologians and others, that we cannot permit Dr. Polk's remarks to pass unnoticed. With due respect to the doctor and his views, we are impelled for truth's sake to deny his definition of Christian Science, or his comparison of it to the methods of hypnotism or suggestive therapeutics. It is unfortunate that he should wish to stand before a gathering of the kind in question and make so unwarranted a statement. It is quite safe to say that there are now more than a million people, many of whom have as high an order of discernment, understanding, and power of analysis, as any to be found, who, speaking from their own investigation, knowledge, and experience, know that there is no relationship or analogy whatever between Christian Science and hypnotism or suggestive therapeutics. They know this with as much certainly as they know any other fact. Many of these persons are not Christian Scientists, but have so far investigated and received the benefits of its system of healing that they have definite knowledge upon the subject. The inseparable gulf between Christian Science healing and the kind of healing referred to by Dr. Polk is this, that the true Christian Science healer goes directly to God, the Supreme Being, in deepest and most devout prayer, setting himself and his own mind absolutely at naught and relying on God for the healing with the implicit faith of the little child, coupled with the understanding of the adult who has been instructed therein; while the mental suggester or hypnotist depends wholly on the power of the human mind, which he believes to be resident in himself, for his healing results. Broadly, plainly, but truthfully speaking, the difference is between the healing taught and practised by Jesus of Nazareth and the imitation thereof by the ancient necromancers and soothsayers. This fact the world will yet learn, and must learn. We therefore say to our brethren of the churches, in all sincerity and candor, that if they wish to take into their churches the true method of Christian healing, they must thoroughly inform themselves as to Christian Science and clearly and resolutely distinguish it from hypnotism, or other methods which rely on any power apart from God.)

Dr. Polk was followed by Mr. W. A. Purrington, who treated the question from a medico-legal point of view. Candor obliges us to say that Mr. Purrington's position—legally speaking—if he is correctly reported, is utterly untenable. His position is at variance with that of courts of the highest authority, including the Supreme Court of the state in which this convention was held—Rhode Island.

In the case of the State vs. Mylod, the Supreme Court clearly recognizes the system of healing through Christian Science as both legal and moral, not only by the necessary effect of the decision, as a whole, but in express language as follows:—

"Prayer for those suffering from disease, or words of encouragement, or the teaching that disease will disappear and physical perfection be attained as a result of prayer, or that humanity will be brought into harmony with God by right thinking and a fixed determination to look of the bright side of life, does not constitute the practice of medicine in the popular sense."

In the case of the State of Ohio vs. Evans, Judge Hollister, passing upon the question of the constitutionality of Christian Science practice, used the following language:—

"The defendant, on being asked to define Christian Science, said:—

"Christian Science is the word of God; it is the practice of Truth which destroys error; it is the life which Jesus asked of us to live, and follows his example in accordance with his command. He says: "Go ye into all the world, preach the Gospel, heal the sick, raise the dead, cleanse the lepers,' and in obedience to this command, when I was asked by the deceased, I obeyed, and if this jury, or any one in this room, any person whatever, persecutor or friend, enemy or any one, comes to me and asks the same, I cannot but obey.'

"From this and other expressions in the record, it is clear that Christian Science is a kind of religious belief.

"Freedom of thought and worship in matters of religion is a birthright of every citizen, and the Legislature cannot take it away or abridge it in any way. It is true that if any practice permitted by any form of religion is against good morals, as, for instance, the polygamy of the Mormons, the people, through their agents, the General Assembly, may protect themselves, and it is doubtless also true that similar protection might be had against any practice considered by the majority to be harmful to the public health. But it must be borne in mind that the claims of power to heal by means regarded generally as miraculous is not confined to those professing belief in Christian Science.

"It is well known that there are many persons in this country, not of this peculiar sect, who devoutly believe that bodily infirmities may be cured by contact with the bones and relics of deceased persons whose lives were of extraordinary holiness. Can it be that the Legislature had such persons in mind, and intended by this legislation to punish the custodian of such articles, if, perchance, he charged a compensation or accepted a gratuity to be expended in their care and preservation? But if this act applies to one class, it must also apply to the other. Is it not most pertinent to assert that if the Legislature had intended to interfere in matters of religion, even if the case were one most proper for interference, it would have plainly said so, and would not have left its meaning to be made the subject of learned arguments and to be declared by judges with common human failings and limitations?

"The Court is of opinion that the law in question does not include such acts as the defendant is charged with having committed, and, for all the reasons given above, the judgment of conviction is reversed."

Mr. Purrington's position is likewise in conflict with views repeatedly expressed in legal publications of high respectability, as well as various nisi prius courts before whom the constitutional question discussed by Mr. Purrington has come.

Law Notes, a legal periodical of good standing, published in Northport, N. Y., in its number for November, 1898, reviewing the question presented in the case of the State vs. Mylod, as well as the general question of Christian Science practice, contains the following concluding statement:—

"It cannot safely be asserted, however, that Christian Scientists are charlatans. If human testimony is worthy of any credit real cures have been accomplished by them, and at the very least substantial peace of mind has been brought through their agency to sufferers pronounced beyond the powers of ordinary physicians. The positive worth of the results achieved by Christian Science is not to be set aside dogmatically or contemptuously; but, even if the doctrine is pronounced a groundless superstition, its believers have a constitutional right to hold and follow what seems to them a system of truth. The law cannot afford to approach the subject in a narrow or intolerant spirit. No one has a right to judge another's beliefs. It is believed, therefore, that the result which the Rhode Island court was able to reach was a most fortunate one, and more in harmony with the spirit of our instit tions and of the age than that which the Supreme Court of Nebraska felt compelled to adopt under the statutes of that State."

Over against Mr. Purrington's dictum, we are glad to place the following statement by the Hon. William G. Ewing, who, at the time he made it, was one of the judges of the Superior Court of Chicago. His remarks, however, were not based upon any question coming before him officially, but were spoken by him out of the depths of his own knowledge an experience, and are entitled to respect and value accordingly:—

"I am persuaded that the dignified course of Christian Scientists everywhere; their constant exhibition of the courage of their convictions, and the consonance of their lives and professions to the teachings of Scripture are by degrees, but certainly, winning the respect, confidence, and conscience of the law-making and law-administering powers; and after all it is not so much the statute, or letter of the la that gives protection, as the moral sentiment of the people touching the right to protection. I have no doubt that the time is not far distant, just how far will depend much upon ourselves, when the legal right to practise Christian Science mind-healing will be as freely and universally conceded as is now acknowledged the right to preach the gospel."

We quote also from the language of a lawyer of many years' experience in the practice, who had also been on the bench, and who in answer to certain questions propounded to him relating to Christian Science practice, in part, said:—

"Do you consider the practice of healing the sick through mental, psychical, or spiritual means, without drugs, a vital part of the Christian Religion as founded by Jesus Christ?

"If I did not consider the practice of healing a vital part of the Christian religion as founded by Jesus Christ, I should not insist upon the legal aspects above set forth. I would prefer rather to accept the healing efficacy of the medical profession. I lay special stress, however, on the words 'spiritual means' used in your question, as distinguished from mental or psychical means. I attach no significance to the words 'mental' or 'psychical' unless they are construed to mean spiritual.

"To those who have not made a special and pains-taking study of mental phenomena, there is a vast unexplored region in the mental realm, an 'undiscovered country,' which, sooner or later, legislators, courts, and juries must take cognizance of and investigate, in order to an intelligent discharge of their duties. Already had this field of investigation been touched by some of the courts, and the necessity for further and intelligent research will become greater and greater as the varied phases of mortal mind or mental phenomena press themselves in upon ordinary human affairs. The question of the undue influence of one human mind upon another, whereby the victim of such undue influence is made to perform acts which, independently, he would not perform, is certain to become one of the grave problems of the future.

"Only by virtue of such an understanding of spiritual law as will enable one to rise above the evils of the human mind, and bring into requisition, through such understanding, the all-present divine Power, can the baneful effects of these false mental phenomena be overcome and destroyed. Here in is the one grand distinction between Christian and un-Christian healing. God is the only healer, and true healing can be accomplished only as the divine law of healing is understood and applied. Jesus taught and proved this law, his disciples did also, and their disciples, down to the latter part of the third century."

In view of the situation, then, it was quite in order for Mr. John Brook Leavitt, a lawyer, to call Mr. Purrington's position in question; which he did, apparently with much acumen and effectiveness. The Providence Journal thus speaks of his remarks, which were made at the close of the general discussion, and were, as we understand, entirely impromptu:—

"John Brook Leavitt, a vestryman of St. Mark's, New York City, was accorded the privilege of adding a few remarks to those of the writers and speakers. He said he wanted to plead with the clergymen to recognize the spirituality of Christian Science and the medical fraternity to recognize the value of mental therapeutics, but he had been agreeably surprised to find that these pleas were unnecessary, as full credit had been given by both clergy and the medical fraternity.

"Mr. Leavitt took serious issue with Mr. Purrington's statement that the practice of mental therapeutics was an offence against the law. No license is required by law, said the speaker, and there is no law which compels either a child or adult to take drugs. No indictment can come for thinking or praying. 'I am sorry to see,' he said, 'that Mr. Purrington has tried to play to Christian Science the role Robert Ingersoll tried to play to the Christian Church, taking detached utterances from its books and commenting thereon.' "

Following Mr. Purrington came the Rev. E. Winchester Donald, from whose able remarks we briefly cull:—

"Is Christian Science leading men out of the darkness of unbelief into the light of God? Yes, it is, it is; there can be no doubt about that. You and I know too many Christian Scientists whose lives are blameless to doubt that, But is Christian Science the only religion? Has the Congregational Church had no saints? Are there no more Methodist saints to-day? As a Christian minister with a fine opportunity to observe I am daily humiliated and exalted by the sight of lives which are lived close to God, and I know that Christian Science has no monopoly of true living. Who was the man who first enunciated the doctrine that matter has no existence but a bishop of the Church of God, Bishop Berkeley, and he was welcomed into the church after he had enunciated this new and startling doctrine."

None more readily than Christian Scientists will endorse Dr. Donald's reference to the saintly lives of the class of Christians to whom he refers, and no one upon this earth has ever more tenderly referred to these, and other devout Christians, than the Rev. Mary Baker Eddy, in her public writings as well as in her private discourses. Dr. Donald, however, when he becomes more familiar with Christian Science, will not wish to stand on record permanently as saying, "A fool or a bad man may employ it; a wise man may not be able to use it at all." It is true that those who are accounted wise by the world cannot use this super-material or spiritual method of healing until they investigate to the point of understanding it, and it is equally true that many who are uneducated, according to the world's standard, grasp the spiritual Truth and do wondrous healing by virtue of it. This is easily accounted for because of the greater receptivity to spiritual truth where there is an absence of cold intellectual barriers; but that bad persons can exercise the divine Power to Leal is not true, as our friends will learn, when they become better acquainted with Christian Science and its adherents.

The fact that a Congress of the dignity and importance of the one under consideration, recognizes Christian Science as a leading factor in modern religious life, is in itself of vast significance. If it were the insignificant and only-to-be-ridiculed thing that some would have the world believe it to be, we may be sure that it would not have so important a place in the church thought. Let us once more assure our friends of the churches that Christian Science is not a foe of the church. Running all through the addresses delivered on this occasion, there was a vein of admission that it contained truth. Truth is of God, and whatever is of God is surely not a foe of the churches. Hence by the admission of those who spoke against it, it is not a foe but a friend. It remains for the churches themselves to determine whether they shall recognize it as a helpful evangel and welcome it accordingly, or whether they will, to the extent of their ability, rule it out of the synagogue. The whole trend of recent events is in the direction of its more friendly reception, and one of the striking evidences of this fact is found in the events here recorded.

Mr. Seward's address is as follows:—

There is but one fact in the universe.

That fact is God.

It is a spiritual fact, for God is Spirit.

It is an ethical fact, for God is Love, Truth, Wisdom, Righteousness; the Supreme Source of all morality.

It is an æsthetic fact, for God is Order, Beauty, Sublimity, Harmony; the Supreme Source of all art.

It is a scientific fact, for God is omnipotent, omniscient, and omnipresent Life; the Supreme Source of all Being and all knowing.

The universe is an outflowing from and expression of the Transcendent God—of His Life, Love, Truth, Wisdom, Order, Beauty, Harmony. This expression in the universe is spiritual and not material, for Spirit could not create anything less than itself or opposite to itself. Man, made in the image of God, is also spiritual, and he is given dominion over all things in the universe.

Jesus Christ, Son of God, son of man, came to save the human race by revealing the truth that is expressed in the foregoing statements. If we imagine a vast insane asylum whose inmates are under one and the same delusion, and that a deliverer voluntarily enters the asylum to lead the inmates out of their delusion by the sacrifice of his time, his talents, and even of his life, we have an analogue which will help to bring the case before our minds.

The delusion of mankind was the belief that the external universe is the real universe. Jesus Christ came as a messenger from the real universe—the spiritual universe—to restore the race to its normal condition of sanity. Human as the son of Mary, divine as the Son of God, he touched humanity on both sides—the side of its delusion and the side of its true being. He said, "The kingdom of God is in the realm of your own consciousness. The law of the kingdom is Love. Obey this law, keep the commandments which grow out of the law of Love, and all other things shall be added unto you; your original dominion over the lesser things of the universe will be re-established." But the Prince of Peace who came to reveal the everlasting Father was nineteen centuries too soon for the full accomplishment of his mission. He was not premature in the divine order, for the seed had to be planted, and he came at the right moment for doing that. Simple natures received the Truth at once, and have done so through all the weary years since his time. They were delivered from the great delusion, and were brought under the law of spiritual life. But the organized Church gradually lost the key. Instead of studying and following the law of Love, the church occupied itself in formulating theories which the late Aubrey Moore characterized as "forensic fictions of substitution, immoral theories of the atonement, the rending asunder of the Trinity, and the opposing of the divine Persons like parties in a lawsuit."

I am to answer the question. What is Christian Science?

Christian Science is a return to the spiritual ideals of Jesus Christ, and an effort to reinstate his standard of life. Christian Science is spiritual knowing, or the knowing which is gained through the spiritual intuition, and not through the intellect; the knowing described by the divine Saviour when he said, "This is life eternal, that they might know thee the only true God, and Jesus Christ, whom thou hast sent."

Spiritual science or spiritual knowing is knowing that if God is infinite, if He is Spirit, if He is Life, Truth, Love, Beauty, Harmony, then there can be no reality in the universe which contradicts or opposes those qualities. Spiritual knowing or spiritual science is knowing that the human race has not wandered from God. That would be impossible, for each member of the race is an individualized expression of the Supreme Creator, and lives, moves, and has his being in Him. He could not be separated from Him for a moment. All man can lose is his consciousness of God; regaining that consciousness is Christian Science, of spiritual knowing.

This Science or knowing is called Christian Science because it is the conviction of those who use the term that no other kind of science or knowing was recognized by Jesus the Christ. His appeal was addressed wholly to man's moral and spiritual nature. He paid no more attention to the brain and its ways than if the organ had no existence. He recognized the material world only in mastering its conditions and rising superior to its lasw. In this he proved himself to be the supreme Scientist of the ages, anticipating the discoveries and conclusions of modern science, which now admits that matter has no objective existence and that Spirit or Mind is the only reality. Professor Borden P. Bowne of Boston University, voices the opinion of a school of philosophy when he says, "A thought-world is the only knowable world; a thought-world is the only real world."

In the limited time allotted to me I can only give the foregoing condensed statement as to what Christian Science is. It is an adaptation of pure Christianity to modern conditions and modern ideas. It is Truth demonstrated. It is Christian teaching revitalized and reduced to practice.

My remaining moments must tell briefly some of the things that Christian Science does.

Concerning the side of the movement which the uninformed public regard as its most important and almost its only feature, namely, the question of healing, I will say but little. On this question the burden of proof does not belong to Christian Science, but to its opponents. Christian Science does heal the sick by the Christ method of realizing the omnipotence of God as Love. Abundant proof is obtainable showing that Christian Science heals both organic and functional diseases, and handles with perfect ease and safety the worst forms of contagious diseases. Now let the theologians bring the sentence from the Word of God to prove that such healing should not be done. If they cannot bring this proof, then let them say why they themselves are not obeying the Master's marching orders: "Preach the gospel," "Heal the sick." There is scarcely a village or hamlet in America that has not one witness or more to the healing power of Christian Science in exemplification of Christ Jesus' words, "The truth shall make you free," and the work is steadily growing in all parts of the world.

And this is not the only challenge of Christian Science to the churches. It says to them, "You have opposed our work hitherto. You have done all in your power to discredit it. Now the burden of proof lies with you again. Search diligently. Investigate thoroughly, and then report the type of life and character you find as the fruit of Christian Science. Do you find its followers to be immoral, dissipated, frivolous, gossipers, mischiefmakers, what St. Paul's letter to Timothy describes as "traitors, heady, highminded, lovers of pleasures more than lovers of God"? Or do you find them moral, meek, striving to know the Mind of Christ and to do the will of God? I have made this investigation for myself, and must bear witness that they invariably stand for the highest morality and the purest spirituality.

Why has the church opposed this movement? For the same reason that it opposed John Wesley and Methodism; because it judges its followers by ecclesiastical standards and not by the Christ standard. I have read the books that have been written against Christian Science, and have this to say about them: They are right in condemning what they condemn, but what they condemn is not Christian Science.

Take the question of sin. Those who do not understand the teaching of Christian Science have an idea that it condones sin because it treats it as an illusion, and not as a reality. I ask you, is there anything more awful than insanity, the hopeless delusion of a diseased mind? Christian Science has impressed me with the disastrous nature of sin far more than scholastic theology ever did, for it has led me to consider the law "to whom ye yield yourselves servants to obey, his servants [his slaves] ye are to whom ye obey." Christian Science holds the terrors of the law over the sinner's head more relentlessly than the church does, for it has no forensic scheme of forgiveness to abate one jot or tittle of his responsibility. Sin is forgiven when it is removed, and not otherwise. Christian Science says as Jesus did, "Sin no more, lest a worse thing come unto thee."

One effect of Christian Science is of immeasurable importance. It brings Christianity back to the child standard, where its divine Founder placed it. The essential distinction between Christ's message and that of Buddha, Confucius, and all other founders of religions, is right at this point. They told the children that they must become like their disciples. Jesus told his disciples that they must become like little children. "Verily I say unto you, Whosoever shall not receive the kingdom of God as a little child shall in no wise enter therein." Ecclesiasticism and scholasticism have utterly ignored that eternal principle. What is the result? The result is well stated by Professor Roswell D. Hitchcock in these words: "After nineteen hundred years of propagandism, Christianity is now compelled to apologize for Christendom."

Christian Science gives the world a new psychology which meets equally the need of the child and of the philosopher. Its fundamental principles are expressed in five postulates:—

1. God is the only Cause.

2. Spirit is the only Substance.

3. Love is the only Force.

4. Harmony, the reflection of Love, is the only Law.

5. Now is the only time.

This is a psychology of the heart and not of the intellect. Intellect is a dethroned king. Its reign is past. Its successor is intuition—soul-perception instead of sense-perception. Why have some of you read the text-book of the new psychology, "Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures," without understanding it? Because you did not have its view-point. It is written from the point of idealism, or the absolutely spiritual, and you read it from the point of the material and intellectual. It is condemned as illogical; but it expresses the logic of the heart, and not of the intellect. Intellect says that man is a combination of matter and spirit, and must die; Jesus said that man is spiritual and will not die if he obeys the laws of Spirit. He came to abolish death.

Christian Science gives its followers a new enthusiasm in studying the Bible. Why? Because its psychology interprets the sacred writings spiritually, and not materially. It reveals the Supreme Being as a God of pure Love, and not as a combination of Love and vengeance.

The psychology of Christian Science is gradually bringing into its ranks a great company of thoughtful people who have been repelled from the churches by the unphilosophical methods of scholastic thought. Yet at the same time it attracts multitudes of simple hearts that receive the Truth, without questioning, as a little child. The common people receive it gladly.

Christian Science provides a spiritual home for a class of people that the churches have not only neglected, but practically ostracized, namely, actors and actresses. The dramatic instinct is one of the fundamental elements of human nature. As we all know, its first expression was religious—in the miracle-plays and passion-plays. Christian Science bridges the gulf which the churches have created between themselves and the members of the theatrical profession. Scores of actors are now coming into the Christian Science Church, and it is the uniform testimony of theatrical managers that these actors are not only transformed themselves, but their influence upon their associates is most beneficent. A single Christian Scientist in a troupe will gradually change the character of the whole company, and substitute harmony for friction and discord.

I will now speak of some of the characteristics of Christian Scientists. They never seek to proselyte. They never solicit patronage. They never advertise except in their own official magazine. They never dedicate a church building till it is paid for. They have a larger church property than any other denomination in proportion to membership. They have a larger average attendance and larger collections. Their church rooms are always open.

The growth of the movement is beyond all precedent. It has been estimated, judging by the past growth and the law of averages, that in fifteen years it will be larger than any other denomination in America, and in twenty-five years it will be larger than all other denominations combined. Why may we expect this growth to continue? Because Christian Science meets a universal human need.

But I hear a cry of alarm, "A woman! a woman! This movement originated with a woman." Well, did not Christianity originate with a woman? Was it not through the Virgin Mary's spiritual concept that the eternal Christ was embodied in the child Jesus? If intuition is to take the place of intellect, then Christianity must be studied and developed from the standpoint of the woman and the child.

The methods of Mrs. Eddy are often criticised as arbitrary and "Popish," but such a rapidly growing body of people could not be led except by a spiritually farseeing leader, and one who follows a direct, well-ordered line of action. Her followers say that her rule is a rule of love and not of fear.

To this her critics reply, "She hypnotizes her followers." I have never seen Mrs. Eddy, and therefore have never come within her "sphere of influence," as the modern phrase goes. But I have talked with many who have seen her and who have felt the power of her presence—the presence of a quiet, refined and retiring personality. Their invariable expression is like that of the two disciples on the way to Emmaus, "Did not our hearts burn within us, while she talked with us by the way, and while she opened to us the Scriptures?" They testify that in her presence they realize the love and power of God as they have never done before, and receive a spiritual uplifting that is never afterward wholly lost. Mrs. Eddy has won her place as one of the great religious leaders of all time. In rapidity of growth and in magnitude of results the Christian Science movement is without a parallel. That she is misunderstood and spoken against is a sign and seal of her ministry. It has been the experience of every emancipator from Moses to Garrison. Even Jesus Christ was called a glutton and a wine bibber, and a friend of sinners.

I am aware that my treatment of this subject is a surprise to some of my audience. But what can I do? When Balaam was called upon by the Moabitish king to curse the children of Israel, he could only give the message that he was inspired by the Spirit of God to give. He doubtless desired to obey the king's command, but when he looked from the mountain-peak upon the fair array of the Jewish camp, he was compelled against his own unworthy purpose to exclaim, "How goodly are thy tents, O Jacob, and thy tabernacles, O Israel!" "How shall I curse, whom God hath not cursed or how shall I defy whom the Lord hath not defied?" "Let me die the death of the righteous, and let my last end be like his."

John Stuart Mill says, "Every question that has God in it passes through three stages: ridicule, discussion, adoption." Dear friends, in considering this very important subject I ask you to remember that five years ago I stood where you stand with reference to Christian Science. Judging from my own experience, and from the history of my gradual change of view, I am led to believe that five years from now all will stand where I now stand who study this system of Truth with an open mind. It has been rightly said that in these transitory times the ministers are leading their people very much as a dog leads a wagon. He runs on ahead, but looks around once in a while to see which way the wagon is going to turn. It is from an instinct of self-preservation on the part of the church, that a layman has been invited to speak to you on this subject. Your members are leaving your congregations and going into the Christian Science fold. Now here is a vital question for you to consider. Are these "apostates" usually of the weak-minded sort who are easily led astray? "Well, no," I have heard many ministers say; "unfortunately some of my best people have taken up with this fad." Is not this fact the best possible evidence that you are mistaken in regarding it as a fad? The truth is, that there is not a Christian Scientist, from Mrs. Eddy down to her latest convert, who wishes the people to leave the churches, if the churches will give their members the Truth that they get in the Christian Science Church. Mrs. Eddy says in her volume of "Miscellaneous Writings," p. 21, "As the ages advance in spirituality, Christian Science will be seen to depart from the trend of other Christian denominations in no wise except by increase of spirituality." And again, on p. 91, "It is not indispensable to organize materially Christ's Church. It is not absolutely necessary to ordain pastors, and to dedicate churches; but if this be done, let it be in concession to the period, and not as a perpetual or indispensable ceremonial of the Church. If our Church is organized, it is to meet the demand, 'Suffer it to be so now.' The real Christian compact is love for one another. This bond is wholly spiritual and inviolate."

It is most important for you to realize that much that goes under the name of Christian Science is something totally and fundamentally different. In justice to yourselves, in justice to the Church, I ask you not to listen to rumors and slanders, but to investigate the question thoroughly, remembering that this is not a superficial movement, but a profound and vital movement. You cannot gain an adequate idea of it without doing three things, namely: attend at least one Sunday service of the Christian Science Church, attend not less than two of the weekly testimonial meetings, and read a recent number of the Christian Science Monthly Journal entirely through. I have been studying the Principle of Christian Science for five years, and I find that the subject will be exhausted when eternity is exhausted.

I will close by saying that the spiritual charter of the Christian Science Church is the 91st Psalm, and the spirit of the movement is indicated by the first two verses, "He that dwelleth in the secret place of the most High shall abide under the shadow of the Almighty. I will say of the Lord, He is my refuge and my fortress: my God; in Him will I trust."

November 22, 1900
Contents

We'd love to hear from you!

Easily submit your testimonies, articles, and poems online.

Submit